A strategic guide to conducting a senior-level job search, covering executive recruiters, personal branding, confidential search tactics, compensation benchmarking, and transition planning.
Last updated:
0 of 20 completed0%
Copied!
Executive Recruiter Relationships
Identify 5-8 executive search firms that specialize in your industry and level
Retained search firms fill most roles above $200,000. Contingency recruiters handle mid-level roles. Research which firms have placed leaders at companies you admire. The wrong firm wastes your time and their credibility.
Reach out to specific recruiters with a targeted introduction
Reference a recent placement they made or a mutual connection. Recruiters receive hundreds of resumes weekly. A warm introduction or a specific reason for contacting them gets your email read instead of filed.
Prepare a confidential executive brief summarizing your experience and target roles
An executive brief is a 1-2 page document that highlights your P&L responsibility, team sizes managed, and measurable business outcomes. This is not a resume. It is a strategic positioning document for recruiter conversations.
Schedule quarterly check-ins with your top 3 recruiter contacts
The best executive opportunities are never posted publicly. Staying in regular contact means you hear about roles months before they appear on job boards. Even if you are not actively searching, maintaining these relationships pays dividends.
Board Network and Personal Branding
Audit your online presence and ensure it reflects your current leadership brand
Search your name and review the first 20 results. Your LinkedIn, published articles, and speaking engagements should dominate. Outdated profiles or irrelevant results dilute your executive presence.
Publish 2-3 thought leadership pieces on industry topics
Write about strategic challenges in your industry, not self-promotional content. Articles published on LinkedIn or industry publications get you invited to speak at events and noticed by board members and hiring committees.
Activate your board and advisory network with discreet outreach
Send personalized messages to 20-30 board members, investors, and senior leaders in your network. Frame it as exploring new opportunities, not desperation. At the executive level, 70-80% of roles come through personal networks.
Seek speaking engagements at 2-3 industry conferences or events
Speaking positions you as a subject matter authority and put you in front of decision-makers. Conference organizers often need speakers 3-6 months in advance. Propose a talk on a challenge your industry currently faces.
Confidential Search Tactics
Establish clear boundaries about who can know about your search
At the executive level, a leaked job search can trigger board concerns, team instability, or preemptive termination. Use a personal email and phone for all search communications. Never use company devices or networks.
Schedule interviews and meetings outside business hours or off-site
Early morning coffee meetings (7am), late afternoon calls, and weekend conversations minimize visibility. If asked about frequent 'appointments,' have a plausible explanation ready that does not involve interviews.
Instruct recruiters to contact you only through preferred channels
Specify your personal cell, personal email, and preferred contact times in writing. A recruiter calling your office line or sending a LinkedIn InMail visible to your team can expose your search prematurely.
Compensation Benchmarking
Research total compensation benchmarks for your target role and market
Executive compensation includes base salary (40-60% of total), annual bonus (20-30%), equity/stock (10-30%), and benefits. Compare total packages, not just base salary. Executive comp surveys from consulting firms provide the most accurate data.
Document your current total compensation package in detail
Include unvested equity, deferred compensation, pension value, and benefits. Changing roles at the executive level means potentially walking away from $50,000-500,000 in unvested compensation. Factor this into your negotiation strategy.
Prepare your negotiation strategy including must-haves and nice-to-haves
Prioritize 3 non-negotiable items and 3 areas with flexibility. At the executive level, negotiate signing bonuses to offset lost unvested equity, guaranteed severance terms, and equity acceleration clauses in case of acquisition.
Reference Preparation
Prepare 6-8 references covering board members, peers, and direct reports
Executive-level reference checks are extensive and often include 360-degree calls. Having references from superiors, peers, and people who reported to you demonstrates well-rounded leadership. Alert each reference before they may be contacted.
Brief each reference on the role and which strengths to emphasize
Share the job description and 2-3 key qualities the hiring company values. A briefed reference who speaks directly to what the employer needs is 5x more impactful than an unprepared one who shares generic praise.
Proactively address any potential negative reference concerns
If you had a difficult departure from a previous role, address it directly with recruiters before they discover it during reference checks. Transparency and your own framing of the situation is always better than letting others control the narrative.
Transition Planning
Plan your departure timeline to minimize disruption to your current organization
Executive transitions typically require 4-8 weeks of notice, not the standard 2 weeks. Plan to leave current projects at natural handoff points. A graceful departure protects your reputation and preserves relationships.
Develop a 90-day plan for your first 3 months in the new role
Outline what you will learn (days 1-30), what you will assess (days 31-60), and what changes you will propose (days 61-90). Presenting this plan during final interviews demonstrates strategic thinking and readiness to lead.
Negotiate your start date to allow for proper rest and preparation
Take 2-4 weeks between roles if financially possible. Executive burnout during transitions is common. Starting a demanding new role without recovery time increases the risk of underperformance in the critical first 90 days.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does an executive job search typically take?
Executive searches average 6-12 months from initial outreach to start date, compared to 3-5 months for mid-level roles. C-suite positions (CEO, CFO, CTO) average 9-14 months. The longer timeline reflects smaller candidate pools, more extensive vetting (multiple board interviews, reference checks spanning 8-12 contacts), and negotiation of complex compensation packages. Starting your search 12 months before your desired transition date is advisable.
Should I use an executive recruiter or search firm?
Retained executive search firms (Heidrick & Struggles, Spencer Stuart, Korn Ferry, Egon Zehnder) fill 60-70% of C-suite and VP-level positions. These firms work for the employer, not the candidate — but building relationships with 3-5 recruiters in your industry ensures you are considered when relevant roles open. Respond to recruiter outreach even for roles you are not interested in — each conversation deepens the relationship for future opportunities.
How important is board experience for executive job candidates?
Board experience is expected for CEO and COO candidates and increasingly valued for VP-level roles. Nonprofit and advisory board seats ($0-$5,000 annual stipend) are accessible starting points that demonstrate governance experience. Corporate board seats are typically available at the Director/VP level and above. Organizations like BoardReady, theBoardlist, and NACD provide training and matchmaking for aspiring board members.
What compensation components should I negotiate in an executive offer?
Beyond base salary, executive compensation includes annual bonus (30-100% of base), long-term incentives (stock options, RSUs, performance shares worth 50-200% of base), signing bonus ($25,000-$500,000), severance protection (6-24 months), change-of-control provisions (golden parachute), relocation packages ($50,000-$200,000), and deferred compensation plans. Each element has different tax treatment — engage a compensation attorney ($2,000-$5,000) to model the total package over a 3-5 year horizon.
How do I maintain confidentiality during an executive job search?
Use a personal email address and phone number for all search communications — never your company-issued devices. Instruct recruiters not to contact references without your explicit approval for each specific opportunity. LinkedIn's 'Open to Work' private setting is visible only to recruiters at companies outside your own. Schedule interviews during personal days, early mornings, or late afternoons rather than during obvious business hours. Limit knowledge of your search to 2-3 trusted confidants.