Evaluate and choose the right meal kit delivery service by comparing cost, portions, dietary options, ingredient quality, and convenience to find the best fit for your household.
Last updated:
0 of 21 completed0%
Copied!
Define Your Needs
Count how many meals per week you need covered
Most services offer 2-5 recipes per week with 2-4 servings each. A household of 2 eating 3 dinners per week from kits needs 3 recipes at 2 servings. Start with 3 meals per week and adjust after the first month.
List your dietary requirements and restrictions
Vegetarian, vegan, gluten-free, low-carb, and calorie-controlled plans are common. Some services offer 20+ weekly options across dietary types; others specialize in one style. Write down non-negotiable requirements before comparing.
Decide your cooking skill level and time budget
Beginner-friendly kits take 20-30 minutes with simple techniques. Intermediate kits run 30-45 minutes with sauteing, roasting, and sauce-making. Some services rate each recipe by difficulty. If you have under 30 minutes per meal, filter by quick-prep options.
Set a weekly budget for meal kits
Most services charge $8-12 per serving, so 3 meals for 2 people costs $48-72 per week. Compare this to your current grocery spending for the same 3 meals. Introductory offers often cut 50-60% off the first 2-4 weeks, but the full price follows.
Compare Service Features
Check the weekly menu variety and rotation
Services offering 20-30 weekly recipes give you more choice than those with 8-10. Check if menus repeat on a 4-6 week cycle. Look at sample menus for 3-4 weeks to see if the variety holds your interest. Some services let you customize proteins.
Compare ingredient quality claims
Some services specify organic produce, antibiotic-free meat, and sustainably sourced seafood. Others use conventional ingredients. Read the fine print — 'premium ingredients' is marketing, while 'USDA organic certified' is a verified standard. Higher-quality ingredients typically add $2-3 per serving.
Review portion sizes and calorie counts
Standard servings range from 500-800 calories per plate. Some services run small — check reviews about portion satisfaction. Meals described as 2 servings should yield 12-16 ounces of food per person. Look for services that list exact nutritional info per recipe.
Check delivery schedules and packaging
Most services deliver once per week on a fixed day. Confirm they deliver to your zip code and that the delivery day works for your schedule. Insulated boxes with ice packs keep food fresh 24-48 hours on your doorstep. Check if packaging is recyclable.
Read the cancellation and skip policies
The best services let you skip weeks with no penalty and cancel online without calling. Some require 5-7 days notice before the next delivery. Read the terms before signing up — services that make cancellation difficult are a red flag.
Trial and Evaluation
Sign up for a discounted trial with 1-2 services
Most services offer 50-65% off the first box, with continued discounts for 2-4 weeks. Sign up for 2 services simultaneously to compare side by side. The trial period is the only honest way to compare taste, freshness, and convenience.
Rate each meal on taste, freshness, and cooking ease
Keep a simple log: recipe name, time to cook, taste rating (1-5), and whether you would make it again. After 6-8 meals, patterns emerge. If you rate most meals 3 or below, that service is not the right fit.
Check ingredient freshness on arrival
Proteins should be cold to the touch (below 40°F). Produce should have no wilting, browning, or soft spots. Ice packs should still be partially frozen. If ingredients arrive warm or damaged, contact support immediately — reputable services will credit or replace the box.
Time yourself cooking each recipe
Compare your actual cooking time to the estimate on the card. If a recipe says 30 minutes and takes you 50, factor that into your decision. Some services consistently underestimate by 10-15 minutes. Track at least 3 recipes to get an accurate average.
Cost Analysis
Calculate the true per-serving cost after introductory pricing
Trial pricing is not your ongoing cost. After discounts end, most services charge $9-12 per serving plus $8-10 shipping. A 3-meal, 2-serving plan runs $62-82 per week at full price. Some waive shipping above $60 per order.
Compare against grocery store costs for the same recipes
Pick 3 recipes from your meal kit and price out the same ingredients at your grocery store. Account for the fact that grocery buying often leaves unused portions (half a bunch of herbs, partial containers). Meal kits eliminate waste by pre-portioning everything.
Factor in the value of time saved on planning and shopping
Meal kits eliminate 30-60 minutes of weekly meal planning and 45-90 minutes of grocery shopping. If your time is worth $20 per hour, that is $25-50 in time savings per week. This narrows the price gap significantly for busy households.
Check if the service reduces your food waste
Pre-portioned ingredients mean you only get exactly what the recipe needs. The average American household wastes $1,500 of food per year. If meal kits cut your waste by even 30%, that is $450 in annual savings to offset the subscription cost.
Making Your Final Decision
Pick the service that fits your top 3 priorities
Rank your priorities: taste, cost, dietary options, convenience, or variety. No service wins in every category. Pick the one that scores highest on your top 3 criteria. A service you enjoy using is better than the cheapest one you dread.
Set a skip schedule to control costs
Order every other week instead of weekly to cut costs in half while still getting the convenience. Skip weeks when you travel, have dinner plans, or want to cook from scratch. Set calendar reminders 6 days before each delivery to decide.
Save favorite recipe cards for future cooking
Keep the recipe cards from meals you loved. After a few months, you will have 15-20 tested recipes you can recreate from grocery store ingredients without the subscription. This is the hidden long-term value of meal kits — cooking education.
Re-evaluate your subscription every 3 months
Your cooking needs change over time. After 3 months, check: Am I still excited to cook these meals? Is the cost still justified? Have I learned enough recipes to cook on my own? Cancel if the answer to 2 of these is no.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much do meal kits cost per serving compared to groceries?
Most meal kit services charge $8-$12 per serving for a standard plan (3 meals per week for 2 people). Grocery cooking the same recipes costs $3-$5 per serving on average. The per-serving cost drops to $6-$9 if you choose a budget-tier service like EveryPlate or Dinnerly. Family plans (4 servings) tend to be $2-$3 cheaper per serving than 2-person plans due to volume.
Which meal kit service has the best variety of recipes?
HelloFresh offers 40+ weekly recipes across multiple cuisine types, the widest selection among major services. Blue Apron rotates 16-20 recipes per week with a focus on chef-designed dishes. Home Chef stands out for customization, letting you swap proteins in any recipe. For specific diets, Green Chef leads in organic/keto/paleo options, and Purple Carrot is the top pick for fully plant-based menus.
Can you cancel a meal kit subscription at any time?
All major meal kit services let you skip weeks or cancel online without penalty -- there are no long-term contracts. Most require you to skip or cancel by Wednesday or Thursday of the week before your next delivery. The cancel process typically takes 2-3 minutes through the account settings page. Watch for services that auto-resume after a certain number of skipped weeks (HelloFresh resumes after 8 skipped weeks unless you fully cancel).
Are meal kits worth it for a family of four?
At $7-$10 per serving for a family plan, a 4-person meal kit runs $28-$40 per dinner. That is cheaper than takeout ($40-$60 per family dinner) but 40-60% more expensive than cooking from grocery-bought ingredients. The real value is time savings -- meal kits cut planning and shopping time by 2-3 hours per week. Families that order takeout 3+ times a week typically save $200-$400 per month by switching to meal kits instead.
How much packaging waste do meal kits produce?
A typical meal kit delivery includes an insulated box, ice packs, and individually wrapped ingredients in plastic bags. The total packaging per meal is roughly 2-3 times what you would generate buying the same ingredients at a grocery store. However, a 2019 University of Michigan study found that meal kits produce 33% fewer greenhouse gas emissions than store-bought meals because they reduce food waste by pre-portioning ingredients. Most services now offer recyclable packaging and prepaid return labels for insulation.