Decide between buying a condo or a single-family house based on your lifestyle, budget, and goals. Covers financial comparisons, lifestyle fit, HOA realities, resale value, and maintenance responsibilities.
condo vs housebuying a condocondo or housefirst home condocondo ownershipsingle family homehome buying decision
Last updated:
0 of 13 completed0%
Estimated time: 2-4 weeks research
Copied!
Compare the True Financial Costs
Calculate the full monthly cost of each option, not just the mortgage payment
A condo's sticker price is typically 20-40% less than a comparable house in the same area, but HOA fees add 200-800 USD per month (some luxury condos exceed 1,500 USD). Your true monthly comparison: mortgage payment plus property taxes plus insurance plus HOA fees (condo) versus mortgage payment plus property taxes plus insurance plus maintenance savings fund (house). A 300,000 USD condo with 500 USD monthly HOA fees costs the same monthly as a 375,000 USD house with no HOA. Run the full numbers side by side before assuming the condo is cheaper.
Research the HOA's financial health by requesting the reserve study and meeting minutes
Before buying a condo, request the HOA's reserve study (shows planned future expenses and savings), current financial statements, meeting minutes from the past 12 months, and any pending or recent special assessments. A poorly funded HOA means surprise special assessments (one-time charges of 2,000-20,000 USD per unit for major repairs like roofing, plumbing, or elevators). Red flags: reserve fund below 70% funded, recent or planned special assessments, ongoing litigation, and deferred maintenance. A healthy HOA with strong reserves protects your investment. A struggling HOA can make your condo unsellable.
Compare insurance costs: condo policies are cheaper but cover less
Condo insurance (HO-6 policy) covers your unit's interior, personal property, and liability. It costs 250-750 USD per year because the building's master policy covers the structure. Homeowners insurance (HO-3 policy) covers the entire structure, personal property, and liability at 1,200-3,000 USD per year. However, review the HOA master policy carefully. Walls-in policies mean you insure everything inside the drywall. All-in policies cover more. The gap between the master policy and your HO-6 is where costly surprises hide. Ask your insurance agent to review the master policy and recommend appropriate HO-6 coverage.
Understand how each option builds equity differently over time
Houses typically appreciate faster than condos (houses average 4-5% per year nationally; condos average 3-4%). Houses also offer more opportunities to add value through renovations (kitchen remodel returns 60-80% of cost at resale). However, condos build equity more predictably because HOA-maintained exteriors prevent deferred maintenance that can reduce a house's value. With a house, you control your equity through maintenance and improvements. With a condo, your equity is partially tied to HOA management decisions you cannot control. Factor in a 5-10 year holding period when comparing long-term financial outcomes.
Evaluate Your Lifestyle Fit
Honestly assess your tolerance for maintenance and yard work
Houses require 15-30 hours per month in maintenance during peak seasons: mowing, landscaping, gutter cleaning, snow removal, appliance repairs, and general upkeep. If you travel frequently, work long hours, or simply hate yard work, a condo eliminates exterior maintenance entirely. However, condo living means relying on the HOA to maintain shared spaces on their timeline, not yours. If you are the type who wants the driveway shoveled at 6 AM, the HOA's snow removal schedule may frustrate you. Be honest about whether maintenance freedom or maintenance control matters more to you.
Consider noise tolerance, privacy needs, and shared wall realities
Condos share walls, floors, and ceilings with neighbors. Even well-built condos transmit some noise (footsteps above, bass from music, early morning routines). If you work from home, are a light sleeper, or need quiet for creative work, shared walls may be a dealbreaker. Before buying a condo, visit the unit at different times of day (morning, evening, weekend) to assess noise levels. Concrete construction transmits less noise than wood-frame buildings. Top-floor and end units have fewer shared surfaces. Houses provide complete sound isolation but come with outdoor noise you cannot control (neighbors, traffic, dogs).
Think about pets, hobbies, and future needs that require space
Many HOAs restrict pet types, breeds, sizes (common limit: 25-50 pounds), and the number of pets per unit. If you have large dogs or plan to get them, verify pet policies before buying. Condos also limit space for hobbies: woodworking, car restoration, gardening, and home gym equipment often need a garage, basement, or yard that condos do not provide. Consider 5-year future needs: starting a family (condos with 1-2 bedrooms become tight fast), working from home permanently (need a dedicated office), or aging in place (single-story houses are more accessible than multi-story condos without elevators).
Understand HOA Rules and Governance
Read the full CC&Rs before buying, not just the summary
The CC&Rs (Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions) are legally binding rules that govern what you can and cannot do with your property. Common restrictions: exterior modifications (paint color, window treatments visible from outside), rental restrictions (minimum lease terms, no short-term rentals), renovation approval process (can take 30-90 days), parking rules (assigned spots, guest parking limits), and quiet hours. The CC&Rs are typically 30-80 pages. Read them completely. If you cannot live with the rules, do not buy. You cannot opt out of CC&Rs after purchase.
Attend an HOA board meeting before buying to see how the community is managed
HOA board meetings reveal the community's culture: are they professional and organized, or contentious and dysfunctional? Common meeting topics: budget approvals, maintenance requests, rule violations, and special projects. Attending one meeting (typically monthly, open to all owners and prospective buyers) tells you more about daily life in the community than any listing description. Ask current residents about their experience with the board. A well-run HOA increases property values and quality of life. A poorly run HOA creates constant frustration and can decrease property values by 5-10%.
Check for any pending litigation involving the HOA
HOAs involved in lawsuits create problems for buyers: lenders may refuse to finance units in buildings with active litigation, insurance rates increase, and special assessments to cover legal costs are common. Ask the HOA management company or board directly about pending or recent litigation. Common HOA lawsuits: construction defect claims (in newer buildings), disputes with developers, lawsuits between the HOA and individual owners, and slip-and-fall liability claims. Active litigation does not always mean avoid the property, but it should prompt deeper investigation and possibly a lower offer price.
Assess Resale and Investment Potential
Research resale trends for condos versus houses in your specific market
National averages do not tell the full story. In some urban markets (Manhattan, San Francisco, Chicago), condos appreciate as well as or better than houses because land is scarce and demand for walkable living is high. In suburban and rural markets, houses consistently outperform condos in appreciation. Pull 5-year and 10-year appreciation data for your specific neighborhood from Zillow, Redfin, or your real estate agent. Also check days-on-market (how quickly properties sell): if condos in your area sit for 90+ days while houses sell in 30, that signals weaker condo demand and potential resale difficulty.
Consider how rising HOA fees affect your condo's future resale value
HOA fees typically increase 3-5% per year. A 400 USD monthly fee today becomes 525 USD in 5 years and 650 USD in 10 years at 5% annual increases. Rising HOA fees reduce the buyer pool because lenders include HOA fees in debt-to-income calculations. A condo with a 1,000 USD monthly HOA fee eliminates many first-time buyers from the market, limiting your resale audience. Before buying, check the HOA's history of fee increases (request 5 years of budget data). Consistent small increases are normal and healthy. Sudden large jumps (20%+ in one year) signal financial problems.
Factor in your expected holding period: condos favor short-term, houses favor long-term
If you plan to stay 2-4 years, a condo often makes more financial sense because the lower purchase price means lower transaction costs (agent commissions, closing costs), and you avoid expensive house maintenance in the early years. If you plan to stay 7+ years, a house typically wins because appreciation outpaces condo gains over longer periods and you avoid cumulative HOA fees that total 42,000-84,000 USD over 7 years at 500-1,000 USD per month. For 5-6 year holds, the decision is closer and depends on your local market. Run the numbers for your specific situation rather than relying on general rules.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are condos a good investment for first-time buyers?
Condos are often the best entry point for first-time buyers in expensive markets where single-family homes are out of reach. The lower price means a smaller down payment (60,000 USD for a 300,000 USD condo at 20% down versus 100,000 USD for a 500,000 USD house). You start building equity instead of renting, and exterior maintenance is handled for you while you learn homeownership basics. The tradeoff: condos appreciate more slowly and HOA fees increase over time. For a first home you plan to keep 3-5 years before upgrading, a condo is a solid stepping stone. For a forever home, a house is usually the better long-term investment.
What happens if I cannot afford a special assessment?
Special assessments are one-time charges for major repairs not covered by the reserve fund (common range: 2,000-20,000 USD per unit). If you cannot pay, most HOAs offer payment plans (6-24 months). If you still cannot pay, the HOA can place a lien on your unit and eventually foreclose (yes, HOAs can foreclose even if your mortgage is current). Before buying, review the reserve study to assess the likelihood of future special assessments. Buildings with roofs, elevators, or plumbing approaching end-of-life are the highest risk. A well-funded reserve (70%+ funded) significantly reduces special assessment risk.
Can I rent out my condo if I move?
It depends entirely on the HOA's CC&Rs. Some condos allow unlimited rentals with no restrictions. Others require minimum lease terms (6 months or 12 months, effectively banning short-term rentals). Some cap the percentage of units that can be rented at any time (typically 20-30%), creating a waitlist for rental permission. A few luxury buildings ban rentals entirely. If you think you might rent your condo in the future (job relocation, buying a second property), verify rental policies before purchasing. Rental restrictions also affect resale because they eliminate investor buyers from your potential buyer pool.
Do HOA fees ever go down?
Extremely rarely. HOA fees cover building insurance, maintenance contracts, utilities for common areas, management company fees, and reserve fund contributions. All of these costs increase over time. The only scenario where fees decrease is when a building pays off a major capital project that was temporarily funded through elevated fees, or when the number of units increases (in expandable developments). Budget for 3-5% annual increases. If an HOA's fees have not increased in several years, that is actually a warning sign: it likely means they are deferring maintenance or underfunding reserves, which leads to sudden large increases or special assessments later.